Lanterns fans are pretty much in agreement that there’s something not quite right with Kelly MacDonald’s Sheriff Kerry Kane, and they think she’s definitely hiding something.

Warning, the following contains mild spoilers for Lanterns season 1 episode 2, so turn back now if you haven’t caught up. First, read our spoiler-free Lanterns review.

After William Macon shoots Hal Jordan, Sheriff Kane takes him to the hospital, where she watches over him while he wakes up from his anesthesia. Once awake, Kane proceeds to tell the Green Lantern that he was saying Sinestro’s name in his sleep. However, fans think the Sheriff was lying. “What if Hal wasn’t actually muttering Sinestro’s name while he was unconscious, and the sheriff said that to plant the idea in Hal’s subconscious to go see him once he got word of the Manhunter?” said one fan on Twitter.

If Hal had been put to sleep, he would’ve had no idea what he had said, which means Kane could have said anything at that point. Also, when Hal checks out of the hospital, he finds that no one else had checked in or out during his stay – which would have been over quite some hours if he had been put under and had surgery. In fact, the whole ward was empty, with hospital equipment still in its packaging. That’s weird, but what is even more strange is that Sheriff Kane didn’t seem to see an issue with it.

But it’s not just the hospital scene. Fans think the show has secretly been hinting at Kane’s dubious energy through clever reflection shots, which you can see below. “The way Lanterns keeps showing Kerry through reflections… there’s definitely something they’re trying to tell us about her,” said the fan. However, despite Kane being on our list of suspects, the poster doesn’t think she is the Manhunter, but that she’s “definitely not who she says she is.”

In the midst of all of the mystery, episode 2 did confirm that Kane is originally from Gotham, which some fans suspected all along after the Sheriff was heard talking to a Commissioner on the phone. In DC Comics, the Kanes are one of the most influential families in the city, and Bruce Wayne’s mother’s maiden name is Kane. The plot thickens.

Lanterns airs weekly on HBO Max and NOW. See our Lanterns release schedule for exact timings. For more, check out our guide to DCU Chapter One and find out where Lanterns takes place on the DCU timeline.