After 8 Years in the Green, Fallout 4’s Steam Rating Crashed to Mostly Negative in Ten Days
News

After 8 Years in the Green, Fallout 4’s Steam Rating Crashed to Mostly Negative in Ten Days

There are two verdicts on every Steam store page, and in November 2025 they told opposite stories about the same game. Fallout 4’s lifetime rating — the verdict built from a decade of players — never budged from Very Positive. Its recent rating, the rolling verdict of the previous thirty days, fell through the floor. On November 20, 2025, ten days after the Anniversary Edition arrived, the base game’s recent reviews sat at “Mostly Negative,” with reporting that day putting just 33 percent of the last month’s reviews on the positive side of the line. It was the first time the recent rating had sunk that low in eight years — and the fall says as much about how Steam’s rating system works as it does about Bethesda’s update.

Boston Common in autumn, with the Massachusetts State House dome behind the trees

Boston Common in November — the real park at the heart of the Commonwealth Fallout 4 recreates, photographed in the same month of the year the game launched in 2015 and re-launched, disastrously, in 2025. Photo: King of Hearts, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).

Two Scores, One Store Page

Steam actually publishes a pair of scores for every game big enough to earn them. The headline number most shoppers recognise is the all-time score: every review ever posted, blended into a single label. Underneath it sits the recent score, calculated only from reviews written in the last thirty days. The two exist to answer different questions. The lifetime score asks whether a game has been good. The recent score asks whether it is good right now — after the latest patch, the latest price change, the latest decision by whoever owns it.

That distinction is the whole story here. Fallout 4 entered November 2025 carrying roughly 400,000 lifetime reviews, about 83 percent of them positive according to the monthly totals tracked by Steambase from Steam’s own data — a Very Positive rating with a decade of momentum behind it. A few thousand angry reviews cannot move a number that size very far, and they did not: the lifetime label stayed Very Positive throughout the crisis. But the recent score has no such ballast. It is a thirty-day window, and in a quiet month for a ten-year-old game, a few thousand reviews are the window. Whoever shows up in force owns it.

In November 2025, the people who showed up were furious — and they were not strangers. Reporting from the period stressed that the wave was led by veterans: players with hundreds or thousands of hours logged, people for whom Fallout 4 was not a purchase they regretted but a hobby that had just been broken underneath them. That is what makes a recent-score collapse different from ordinary launch-day grumbling. The thirty-day window filled up with the game’s own most invested audience, voting thumbs-down on the current state of something they had spent years voting thumbs-up on.

What “Mostly Negative” Actually Means

Steam reviews are binary. There is no star rating, no score out of ten — a reviewer either recommends the game or does not, and the labels are just names for bands of that percentage. At the top, a game with at least 95 percent positive reviews across 500 or more reviews earns Overwhelmingly Positive; the 80 percent neighbourhood earns Very Positive once there are enough reviews to trust it. Below that sit Mostly Positive for the seventies, and Mixed for the broad, uneasy band between 40 and 69 percent positive.

Mostly Negative is the band beneath Mixed: between 20 and 39 percent of reviewers recommending the game. Below it there is still further to fall — Negative, Very Negative, and Overwhelmingly Negative for games under 20 percent — which is worth remembering, because it frames what happened to Fallout 4 precisely. The game did not become one of the most hated objects on Steam. It fell from the comfortable eighties, where it had lived for years, through Mostly Positive and Mixed, and landed in the twenties and low thirties: a band that tells a browsing stranger, in one glance, that something has recently gone badly wrong. For a flagship RPG from a major publisher, simply being seen in that band is the punishment. The red label beside the buy button does the work.

Panorama of the Boston skyline seen from across the Charles River in Cambridge

The Boston skyline from Cambridge, across the Charles River — the city Fallout 4 shrank into its post-apocalyptic Commonwealth, and the backdrop for a tenth-anniversary celebration that turned into a protest. Photo: King of Hearts, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).

Ten Days That Sank Eight Years

The Anniversary Edition launched on November 10, 2025 — exactly ten years after the original game — bundling the base game, its six expansions, and more than 150 pieces of Creation Club content. Crucially for the rating, the release was not opt-in. A mandatory update rolled out to every existing owner, rebuilding parts of the game’s menus around the new Creations system whether a player had bought anything new or not. The launch-day chaos — broken installations, content that would not register as owned, a flood of crashes — is its own chapter of this saga. What matters here is the meter, and the meter moved fast.

Within the first couple of days, Windows Central was reporting that only 44 percent of the game’s 4,225 recent reviews were positive — already down in Mixed territory, and dropping as the count climbed. By November 19, TheGamer reported the recent positive share down to 25 percent and noted that the recent rating had dipped to Mostly Negative for the first time since 2017. On November 20, FRVR’s snapshot of the thirty-day window put the positive share at 33 percent with the Mostly Negative label attached. The two figures are not a contradiction so much as a strobe light: the percentage was swinging daily depending on when in the flood the snapshot was taken, but every reading told the same story of a rating in freefall.

Two days later, GameRant, working from SteamDB figures drawn from Valve’s API, put hard totals on the wave: in the twelve days leading up to November 22, Fallout 4 had collected more than 7,500 negative reviews, and 90.93 percent of all reviews posted in that span were negative. Nine out of every ten people who felt moved to review the game in that window were there to warn others off. That is the arithmetic of a collapsed recent rating — not a slow erosion of goodwill, but a fortnight in which the thumbs-down outnumbered the thumbs-up roughly ten to one.

What the Thumbs-Down Were Actually Saying

Read in bulk — and this feature paraphrases themes rather than quoting at length — the negative reviews cluster around a handful of grievances, repeated with remarkable consistency. The largest was mod breakage. Fallout 4’s PC afterlife runs on mods, and any update that ships a new executable breaks the script extenders and load orders those mods depend on. Players described returning to installations refined over years and finding them unable to start, or starting only after the kind of full teardown nobody schedules voluntarily around a game’s birthday.

Second came plain instability: crashes on launch, crashes when quitting to desktop, freezes inside the new Creations menu, and error text where location names should have been. Third came the ownership failures — players whose previously bought downloadable content was no longer recognised as theirs, and buyers of the new bundle who could see their purchase listed but could not get the content to install. Layered over all of it was a pricing grievance: the sense, voiced again and again in the reviews, that a decade-old game had been re-sold as a celebration while the free mandatory update broke the version people already owned. One widely circulated Steam review, quoted in coverage at the time, framed the update cycle as sabotage dressed as support — breaking mods, forcing the update, and re-selling familiar content under fresh monetised paint. Another simply thanked Bethesda, with heavy sarcasm, for breaking a favourite game after some 2,500 hours in it. The stub of the original story says it in three words: “Why, Bethesda?!”

A PC gaming motherboard photographed from above, showing its slots, chipset and circuitry

The hardware end of the argument: Fallout 4’s PC community builds its game on motherboards like this one, layering hundreds of mods onto the base install — which is why an update that breaks load orders lands as a personal loss, not a patch note. Photo: PantheraLeo1359531, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0).

A Bomb, or a Bug Report With a Thumbs-Down?

The standard word for what happened is “review bomb,” and it deserves a moment’s scrutiny, because Steam itself maintains a distinction that matters. Since 2019, Valve has operated a policy on what it calls off-topic review bombs: when its detection tools flag anomalous review activity, human reviewers decide whether the grievance is unrelated to whether a future buyer would enjoy the game — a protest about a publisher’s other titles, say, or a store-exclusivity decision. If it is off-topic, Valve marks the period and excludes those reviews from the score calculation, while leaving the review texts themselves readable.

The November 2025 wave fits that exclusion badly, which is precisely why it stuck. The complaints were about this game, as it ran that month: crashes, unusable menus, purchased content that would not install, mod configurations destroyed by a compulsory patch. A future buyer reading those reviews was learning exactly what buying Fallout 4 on PC that autumn entailed. That is the difference between a bomb and a pile-up of bug reports wearing a thumbs-down — and Steam’s histogram, the month-by-month graph on every store page, preserves either kind permanently. Whatever label the thirty-day window carried afterwards, November 2025 remains visible in that graph forever, a red trench cut through a decade of mostly blue.

Fallout 4 Had Been Here Before — Twice

Long memories in the community immediately reached for 2017, and the comparison holds up in the data. GameRant’s table of the game’s bombing campaigns records the Creation Club backlash of August to October 2017 at 18,613 negative reviews, with 88.64 percent of that period’s reviews negative; TheGamer’s look at the store graph found the recent positive share bottoming near 19 percent in September 2017. The provocation then rhymes with the one in 2025: paid mod content arriving through the Creation Club, and game files being pushed onto players who had not asked for them. Eight years of positive recent ratings — the stretch the original headline counted — is exactly the distance between that trench and this one.

The middle entry in the table is the instructive one. When the next-gen update arrived in April 2024 and broke mods all over again, the backlash was real but proportionally far milder: 7,403 negative reviews across April and May 2024, yet only 22.68 percent of the period’s reviews were negative — meaning the majority of people reviewing the game in those months still recommended it, and the recent rating never fell anywhere near the November 2025 depth. Set the three episodes side by side and the 2025 wave stands apart not for its raw count, which 2017 exceeded, but for its purity: at 90.93 percent negative, it was, percentage-wise, the most one-sided verdict the game’s reviewers have ever delivered.

The Company It Keeps

Fallout 4’s collapse belongs to a recognisable genre. In May 2024, Sony announced that Helldivers 2 players on PC would be required to link a PlayStation Network account — a demand that would have locked out buyers in the many countries where PSN does not operate. More than 200,000 negative Steam reviews landed in a matter of days, Sony reversed the requirement within the weekend, and the story took its rarest turn: fans organised a deliberate clean-up campaign, flipping their reviews back to positive in such numbers that the rating visibly recovered. Review bombing, there, functioned as a recall petition that worked in under a week.

The darker pole is Overwatch 2, which arrived on Steam in August 2023 and within days became the worst-reviewed game on the platform, with roughly 91 percent of more than 100,000 reviews negative — a verdict on years of accumulated grievances, from monetisation to the cancelled cooperative mode, finally given a Steam page to land on. Its lifetime rating carried that scar long afterwards, even as its recent reviews eventually clawed back up to Mixed. The contrast with Fallout 4 is instructive: Overwatch 2’s bomb was a lifetime event for a game with no positive history on the store, while Fallout 4’s was a recent-window event layered on top of an unshakeable lifetime score. Same weapon, different wound.

The Long Climb Back

So did the rating recover? The honest answer, from the checkable record, is: the lifetime score barely noticed, and the recent score healed the way recent scores always do — by waiting. Steambase’s monthly totals, drawn from Steam’s data, show the lifetime tally sliding from about 83 percent positive in October 2025 to roughly 81.5 percent in November — a real dent of nearly two points, which at this scale represents those thousands of negatives landing at once — and then settling at about 81 percent, still labelled Very Positive, where it remained through the latest totals available in October 2026: 349,407 positive reviews out of 430,369 in all. Eleven thousand players were still in-game on an ordinary October 2026 day, per trackers cited that month, and Bethesda was still patching the game as late as May 27, 2026.

The recent rating’s recovery can be read out of the same monthly arithmetic, even though no single report pinned the day the label changed. Of the reviews added in December 2025, about 47 percent were positive — the profile of a rating climbing out of Mostly Negative back through Mixed as the November flood aged out of the thirty-day window. January 2026’s new reviews ran about 70 percent positive, and February’s about 84 percent — figures squarely back in the game’s normal habitat. In other words, the red label was a season, not a sentence: roughly a quarter in which the thirty-day window belonged to the protest, followed by a quiet return to the verdict the previous eight years had delivered.

What did not recover is harder to graph. The November trench stays in the histogram permanently. The players who uninstalled rather than rebuild a broken load order mostly did not write follow-up reviews saying so. And the episode completed a pattern the community can now recite from memory — a Bethesda anniversary re-release, a compulsory update, a broken mod ecosystem, a red month on Steam — that had already played out once with Skyrim’s own Anniversary Edition and once with this game’s next-gen patch. The Steam rating, in the end, did exactly the job its designers gave the recent score: it told the truth about one bad month, loudly, in red, next to the buy button — and then, month by month, it went back to telling the older truth too.

One email a week: the best new articles, hidden gems, and zero spam. Insert coin to continue.