
We first posted about this remake back in October 2014, when it was a hopeful announcement and a 61-word news stub was all the story seemed to need. It turned out to be the start of a much longer one. In the decade since that little post, the remake has been released, shut down by Lucasfilm, mourned as dead, and then — quietly, without any announcement at all — brought back to life. Consider this the follow-up, eleven years late: the whole story, including the part where it turns out you can play it.
The Fourth Indy Film, Delivered on Floppy Disks
First, the game itself, because everything that follows only makes sense if you understand what was being remade. Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis arrived from LucasArts in June 1992, at the absolute peak of the studio’s point-and-click powers — the same SCUMM-engine lineage that produced The Secret of Monkey Island and Day of the Tentacle. Director Hal Barwood and co-designer Noah Falstein built an entirely original Indy story rather than adapting a film: in 1939, Dr. Jones is pulled from teaching at Barnett College into a race against Nazi agent Klaus Kerner, who is hunting the lost city of Atlantis and the orichalcum metal that powered it. Indy’s partner in the search is Sophia Hapgood, a former archaeologist turned stage psychic, and the banter between the two carries the game the way it carries the films.

Its masterstroke was structural. Partway through, the game asks how you want to play it and splits into three largely separate routes — the Team path, adventuring alongside Sophia; the Wits path, leaning into elaborate puzzles; and the Fists path, where Indy solves more problems with his hands. Three versions of the middle of the game, all converging on the same lost city. A CD-ROM “talkie” edition followed in 1993 with a full voice cast, and the game’s reputation has only grown since: it is routinely described as the fourth Indiana Jones film that cinema never gave us — a line so durable that the producer of 2024’s The Great Circle was still saying it, on the record, thirty years later.

2014: The Fans Pick Up the Whip
By 2014, Fate of Atlantis had been re-released digitally and was easy to buy — but it looked like what it was: a beautiful early-nineties game in chunky pixels. The team at Went2Play, led by Patrik Spacek, wanted to find out what it would look like made the modern way. Their Special Edition was a from-the-ground-up remake: every background repainted as rich HD artwork, new animation, new music, new sound effects, and new voiceovers, wrapped around Barwood and Falstein’s original design. Our own stub from that October caught the announcement while the project was still young — we told you fans were re-creating the game in high definition, and signed off — and for a while the story went the way fan-project stories are supposed to go. A playable demo was released to the public. The team, knowing a fan remake lives at the rights holder’s mercy, petitioned Lucasfilm for a license to finish and release the game properly.

A Polite No From Lucasfilm
In March 2017, the answer arrived, and it was no. As DSOGaming reported at the time, Lucasfilm informally asked Went2Play to stop developing and distributing the remake — the demo downloads were taken down on March 5, 2017. There was no lawsuit, no public drama; just a quiet word and a project switched off. Lucasfilm, in the team’s telling, simply didn’t want to share the Indy license with anyone right now. It was the ending most fan remakes get, and for most observers it was the end of the story.
Except the team never quite announced it was over. In January 2018, nearly a year after the takedown, Spacek surfaced in the Steam forums to say they were still working on it: the first demo was gone, but a second demo was in development. And then — silence. Year after year of it. The project’s public trail went so cold that by May 2025, a commenter on that same Steam thread delivered the obvious verdict: “guess this is dead.” It was a reasonable call. It was also wrong.
It Belongs in a Museum — So It Came Back
The remake is alive again, in public, right now. Went2Play — now Went2Play LLC — has a page on itch.io for Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis Special Edition, and it isn’t a memorial: it’s a playable demo build, presented as the non-profit fan project it always was, with an open invitation to play it and talk to the team on Discord. Players are finding it, too — the page carries a 5.0 rating, albeit from a small handful of ratings so far. The screenshots on the page are the real evidence: the college basement, the storeroom with its horned idol, Sophia’s stage show and her ransacked, spirit-haunted office, all rebuilt in the same lush style the 2014 announcement promised.

Honesty matters here, because a resurrection headline can run ahead of the facts. What lives on itch.io is a demo, not the finished game. There is no evidence the full remake was ever completed, and no evidence Lucasfilm ever granted the license the team asked for — the 2017 “no” is the last word on that subject anyone has published. What changed is narrower and, for a project like this, remarkable enough: after eight years in the dark, the work exists somewhere the public can actually reach it again, credited to its makers and dated 2025.
How to Play Both, Today
Start with the original, because it has never been easier: the 1993 talkie edition of Fate of Atlantis is sold on both Steam and GOG, runs happily on modern machines, and remains — three paths, nine verbs and all — one of the finest adventure games ever made. If you have somehow never played it, that is the museum piece, and it belongs at the top of your list. Then play the remake: the demo is free on the team’s itch.io page, and it is worth your time for what it is — a glimpse of the parallel-universe version, the same rooms and the same story drawn the way 2014 imagined 1992 could look. Fan projects are supposed to end the way this one did in 2017 — with a polite letter and a dead download link. This one is downloadable. Against every odd in the book, that makes it the happiest ending a fan remake gets.
Keep reading: “Fate of Atlantis Felt Like the Movie We Never Got” — the Great Circle team on the game’s legacy · Fate of Atlantis Was Almost Based on an Unproduced Indy Script · Three Friends, One House, Three Centuries: The Making of Day of the Tentacle
